Baked Goods

/Baked Goods
Baked Goods2026-09-09T16:38:46-04:00
  • Vienna Slices

 

Bakery Counter Prices

Cookies

Chocolate Chip 1.25
Oatmeal Raison 1.25
Macadamia Nut 1.25
Salted Caramel 1.25
Ginger Molasses 1.25
Peanut Butter 1.25
Double Chocolate 1.25
Ice Box 1.69
Sugar 1.69
Chocolate Macaroons 1.69
Shortbread Sandwich 1.69
Empire 2.99
Buttercream Iced Sugar Cookie 2.99
Gingerbread 2.99
S'mores Cookie 2.99
Melting Snowman 2.99
8" Heart or Round Chocolate Chip Cookie 17.99

Tarts

Butter tart – 2.49
Pecan tart – 2.49
Fern tart – 2.49
Portuguese tart – 2.49

Pastries

Cream Horns 2.99
Custard Horns 2.99
Eclairs 3.49
Custard Slices 4.99
Vienna Slices 4.99
Raspberry Flakie 4.99

Squares

Skor Bars 2.79
Reese Bars 2.79
Brownies 2.49
Walnut Chews 2.49
Pecan Chew 2.49
Date Squares 2.49
Nanaimo Bars 2.49
Salted Caramel Bars 2.79
PBFB 1.25
Rum Balls 1.25

Cupcakes

Cupcakes – Chocolate & White 3.89
Cupcakes – Gluten Free 4.49
Cupcakes – Vegan 4.49
Cupcakes – Carrot 4.49
Cupcakes – Red Velvet 4.49
Cake Slice 4.49
Mini Cheesecake 2.49

Dessert Cakes

Chocolate Fudge Sprinkle Cake 28.99
White Butter Cream Sprinkle Cake 28.99
White Custard Whip Cream Sprinkle Cake 28.99
Valentine Heart Shape Cake 8" 44.95

Pies

Coconut Custard 13.99
Banana Cream 13.99
Boston Cream 13.99

Dozen Pricing

Buy 10 same priced items and get 2 Free

To Our Subs Plus Family

During this time due to Covid-19, we will be OPEN for Cake Orders Only. We hope to be fully operational soon. Store hours are Wednesday-Sunday 12pm-4pm. Cake orders can be placed by phone or online with Order Cake Now menu. We appreciate your understanding and apologize for any inconvenience. Stay Safe Niagara